The Pizza Cutters Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to The Pizza Cutters, a delightful gem in Syracuse serving up an impressive array of specialty pizzas, calzones, and wings that will tantalize your taste buds. Located at 3712 New Ct Ave, this eatery boasts a reputation for both quality and customer service.

  • Signature Pizzas: From classic cheese and pepperoni to innovative flavors like garlic broccoli and chicken bacon ranch, there’s something for everyone.
  • Wings and More: Indulge in their well-loved wings, especially the Whiskey Apple Bourbon flavor that customers rave about.
  • Generous Portions: Customers are consistently impressed by the substantial sizes of dishes, including the colossal calzones and stromboli.
  • Welcoming Atmosphere: Patrons have noted the friendly and attentive staff, making every visit feel special.

With quick service and delectable offerings, The Pizza Cutters is a must-visit for both locals and newcomers!

Subs/Wraps/Panini's

Boom Boom Chicken

Fried chicken, boom boom sauce, mayo, lettuce, tomatoe

US$9.89

Chicken Cordon Bleu

Chicken tenders, Virginia baked ham, Swiss cheese and mayo.

US$9.89

Chicken Philly

Grilled marinated chicken, onion, mushroom, green pepper and American cheese.

US$9.89

Cold Cut

Select from our hand carved meats. Choose from rustic sub roll, wrap or panini. Customize the way you like!

US$0.00

Buffalo Chicken Melt

Chicken tenders dipped in Buffalo sauce, with blue cheese and mozzarella. Flame toasted to perfection!

US$9.89

Steak Parmigiana

Shaved steak, red sauce and mozzarella.

US$9.89

BLT

Crispy bacon, mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, onion and American cheese.

US$9.89

California Club

US$9.89

Chicken Parmigian

Fried or grilled chicken, red sauce and mozzarella.

US$9.89

Chicken Tender

Breaded chicken tenders, mayo, lettuce, tomatoe and American cheese on a rustic submarine roll

US$9.89

Turkey Club

Turkey, Hardwood Smoked Bacon, Mayo Lettuce, Tomato, American

US$9.89

Buffalo Chicken Tender

Buffalo. Chicken tenders, mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, onion and American cheese.

US$9.89

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Fried or grilled chicken, bacon, ranch and mozzarella.

US$9.89

Grilled Chicken

Grilled chicken, mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, onion and American cheese.

US$9.89

Steak Philly

Shaved steak, onion, mushroom, green pepper and mozzarella.

US$9.89

Ham & Swiss

US$9.89

Meatball Parmigian

Homestyle meatballs, house red sauce and mozzarella.

US$9.89

Eggplant Parmigan

Fried eggplant, house red sauce and mozzarella.

US$9.89

Chopped Cheese

US$9.89

Chicken Teriyaki

US$9.89

Large Wood Fire

US$17.99

Medium Wood Fire

US$14.99

Small Wood Fire

US$12.99

Wood Fire Pizza

Seafood

Shrimp Po Boy

Battered Shrimp, chipotle mayo, lettuce, tomato, pickles Add Fries 2.00

US$11.99

Boom Boom Shrimp Dinner (9)

US$12.99

Buffalo Shrimp (9)

US$8.99

Battered Clams Strips

US$9.99

Haddock Sandwich

US$10.99

Battered Shrimp (9)

US$9.99

Haddock Dinner

16 oz lightly breaded haddock. Served with coleslaw, tarter and roll

US$13.99

Clam Strips Dinner

US$12.99

Calamari Rings

With marinara

US$10.99

Shrimp Dinner (9)

US$12.99

Boom Boom Shrimp (9)

US$9.99

Sheet Pizza

US$30.99

Monster Pizza

US$34.99

Large Pizza

US$17.99

Medium Pizza

US$14.99

X-Large Pizza

US$19.99

Personal Pizza

US$12.99

Gluten Free Pizza

US$12.99

Brick Oven Pizza

Award Winning Wings

5 Wings

US$8.99

10 Wings

US$16.99

12 Boneless Wings

US$13.99

The Hangover

US$13.99

The Honkey Tonk

US$13.99

The Lumberjack

US$13.99

The Smash Burger

US$13.99

The Deluxe

1/2 lb flame broiled angus steak burger, mayo, ketchup, bacon, American cheese. Served with a side of fries

US$13.99

The Black & Blue

1/2 lb flame broiled angus steak burger, mayo, bacon and crumbly bleu. Served with a side of fries.

US$13.99

Plane Cheeseburger

US$13.99

The Waldorf

US$13.99

The Boom Boom

1/2 lb Angus Beef, Pepperjack Cheese, Jalapenos, and Boom Boom sauce

US$13.99

The Rodeo

1/2 lb flame broiled angus beef steak burger, gourmet onion rings, American cheese, bbq sauce, served with a side of fries

US$13.99

The Heart Attack

1/2 lb angus beef , bacon and cheddar between 2 glazed donuts

US$13.99

The Miss Daisy

US$13.99

The Swiss Mush

1/2 lb flame broiled angus steak burger, mayo, lettuce, tomatoe, sauteed mushrooms, Swiss cheese. Served with a side of fries.

US$13.99

The Bacon Cheddar

1/2 lb angus beef steak burger, cheddar, bacon, sauteed onion, served with a side of fries

US$13.99

The Classic

1/2 lb flame broiled angus beef steak burger, mayo, ketchup,mustard, lettuce, tomato, pickles, American cheese, served with a side of fries

US$13.99

Gourmet Burgers

Specialty Pizza

Caprese Pizza

US$0.00

Greek Pizza

Garlic sauce, spinach, feta, diced tomatoes and mozzarella. Topped with Parmigian and oregano.

US$0.00

Margherita Pizza

House red sauce with fresh basil and fresh mozzarella

US$0.00

Chicken Pesto Pizza

Pesto garlic sauce, fried or marinated grilled chicken, diced tomatoes, diced onion and banana peppers.

US$0.00

Supreme Pizza

Red sauce base with onion, green pepper, mushroom, sausage, pepperoni and mozzarella.

US$0.00

Meat Lovers Pizza

Sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon, meatball and mozzarella.

US$0.00

Vodka Chicken Pizza

Vodka sauce, fried or marinated grilled chicken. Topped with oregano and Parmigian.

US$0.00

BBQ Chicken Pizza

House BBQ sauce, fried or grilled chicken and mozzarella.

US$0.00

Steak Philly Pizza

garlic sauce, shaved Philly steak, onion, green pepper, mushroom and mozzarella. Topped with steak seasoning.

US$0.00

Chicken & Waffle Pizza

Maple Syrup Garlic Base with Fried Chicken and Belgium Waffles with a Hot honey and maple syrup drizzle

US$0.00

Hawaiian Pizza

Red sauce, ham, pineapple chunks and mozzarella.

US$0.00

Veggie Pizza

red sauce, red onion, green pepper, mushroom, broccoli, black olive and mozzarella.

US$0.00

The Big Mac

US$0.00

Chicken Balsamic Ranch

Garlic base pizza , mozzarella cheese, fried chicken, ranch and balsamic glaze, parm, oregano

US$0.00

Chicken Parmigian Pizza

House red sauce, fried chicken and topped with oregano and parmigian.

US$0.00

Breakfast Pizza

Garlic base, eggs, mozzarella, cheddar, ham, bacon

US$0.00

Loaded Fry Pizza

Sour cream, crispy fries, hardwood smoked bacon, mozzarella and cheddar.

US$0.00

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Garlic base with either fried or grilled chicken, bacon, mozzarella topped with a drizzle of ranch

US$0.00

Boom Boom Chicken Pizza

Boom Boom sauce base. Fried or grilled chicken and mozzarella topped with oregano and parmesan

US$0.00

Buffalo Chicken Wing Pizza

Our Buffalo Sauce base with fried or marinated chicken, mozzarella topped with blue cheese drizzle

US$0.00

Firework Fries Pizza

Our Specialty Firework Fries, now as a Pizza Loaded up with fries, fried chicken, jalapenos, mozzarella, cheddar, topped with boom boom sauce

US$0.00

Chicken Philly Pizza

garlic sauce, marinated grilled chicken, onion, green pepper, mushroom and mozzarella.

US$0.00

Chicken Alfredo Pizza

US$0.00

Baked Lasagna Pizza

House red sauce, crumbled sausage, meatball, ricotta and mozzarella. Topped with Parmigian and oregano.

US$0.00

Baked Potato Pizza

Sour cream base, potato, onion, hardwood smoked bacon, mozzarella and cheddar.

US$0.00

The DSP

US$0.00

Grandma's Pie

Upside down, sauce on top, tons of fresh basil. Just like grandma used to make

US$0.00

Eggplant Parmigian Pizza

House red sauce, fried eggplant, topped with Parmigian, oregano and mozzarella.

US$0.00

Large Chicago Style Pizza

US$19.99

Medium Chicago Style Pizza

US$16.99

Small Chicago Style Pizza

US$13.99

Chicago Style Pizza

Salads

Greek Salad

Chef Salad with Lamb Gyro Strips & Feta Cheese

US$0.00

Antipasto

Chef salad with ham, salami and provolone.

US$0.00

Grilled Chicken Salad

Chef salad with grilled marinated chicken

US$0.00

Julienne Salad

Chef salad with turkey, ham and Swiss.

US$0.00

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Chef Salad with Marinated or Fried Chicken tossed in Buffalo Sauce

US$0.00

Chicken Caesar

US$0.00

Chef Salad

Romaine blend, tomatoes, green pepper, banana pepper, black olive, onions, shredded carrots & cabbage

US$0.00

Caprese Salad

US$8.79

Marinated Steak Salad

Chef Salad with Shaved Marinated Steak

US$0.00

Pure Leaf Tea Raspberry

US$2.99

Gatorade Fruit Punch

US$2.99

20 Oz Soda

US$2.99

Rockstar Fruit Punch

US$2.99

Rock Star Original

US$2.99

2 Ltr Drinks

US$3.99

Bottled Water

US$2.99

Drinks

Heart Shaped Pizza

Heart Shaped X-Large Pizza

US$20.99

Heart Shaped Medium Pizza

US$14.99

Heart Shaped Small Pizza

US$12.99

Heart Shaped Large Pizza

US$18.99

Greek Calzone

Garlic sauce, spinach, feta, diced tomatoes, mozzerrela

US$14.99

Fire Work Fry Calzone

French fries, mozzarella, cheddar, fried chicken, jalapeno, ranch, boom boom sauce

US$14.99

Dill Pickle Calzone

Mozzarella cheese, sliced pickles, oregano, parmigiana

US$14.99

Vodka Calzone

Vodka sauce, fried or marinated grilled chicken, mozzarella

US$14.99

Poutine Calzone

French fries, brown gravy, cheese curd, mozzarella cheese

US$14.99

Stromboli

Folded dough filled with marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese. Baked and brushed with house garlic sauce. Topped with Parmigian and oregano.

US$13.99

Loaded Fry Calzone

Sour cream, crispy fries, hardwood smoked bacon, mozzarella and cheddar.

US$14.99

Baked Potato Calzone

Sour cream base, potato, onion, hardwood smoked bacon, mozzarella and cheddar.

US$14.99

Margherita Calzone

House red sauce, fresh basil, mozzarella cheese

US$14.99

Hawaiian Calzone

House red or garlic sauce, ham, pineapple chunks, mozzarella and ricotta

US$14.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone

Garlic sauce, fried or marinated grilled chicken, hardwood smoked bacon, ranch, mozzerrela

US$14.99

BBQ Chicken Calzone

House BBQ sauce, fried or grilled chicken, mozzerrela

US$14.99

Caprese Calzone

Mozerella, fresh basil, tomatoes, balsamic glaze

US$14.99

Veggie Calzone

House red or garlic sauce, red onion, green pepper, mushroom, broccoli, black olive, mozzarella

US$14.99

Supreme Calzone

Red or garlic sauce, onion, green pepper, mushroom, sausage, pepperoni, mozzerrela

US$14.99

Boom Boom Chicken Calzone

Sour cream, crispy fries, hardwood smoked bacon, mozzarella and cheddar.

US$14.99

Philly Steak Calzone

Red or garlic sauce, shaved Philly Steak, onion, green pepper, mushroom, mozzarella, Topped with Steak Seasoning

US$14.99

Baked Lasagna Calzone

House red sauce, crumbled sausage, meatball, mozzarella and ricotta

US$14.99

Calzone

Our housmade dough filled with mozzarella cheese and ricotta cheese. Folded, baked and brushed with garlic butter and shakers

US$13.99

Buffalo Chicken Wing Calzone

Your choice of sauce, blue cheese, fried or marinated grilled chicken, mozzarella

US$14.99

Eggplant Parmigian Calzone

House red sauce, fried eggplant, mozzarella

US$14.99

Philly Chicken Calzone

Red or garlic sauce, Marinated Grilled Chicken, onion, green pepper, mushroom, mozzarella

US$14.99

Chicken Parmigian Calzone

House red sauce, fried chicken, mozzarella

US$14.99

Chicken And Waffle Calzone

Chicken, Belgian waffles, mozzarella, cheddar, maple syrup, hot honey

US$14.99

Meat Lover's Calzone

Sausage, pepperoni, ham, bacon, meatball, mozzarella and riccotta

US$14.99

Calzone & Strombolis

Desserts

Cinnamon Bread-Sticks

Fluffy bread sticks made with our house made dough. Brushed with cinnamon and topped with graham cracker crumble and powdered sugar

US$10.99

Oreo Cheesecake Calzone

US$12.99

Oreo Calzone

Folded dough, filled with Oreo crumbles and marshmallows, baked and brushed with cinnamon butter and topped with Oreo crumbles. Served with icing on the side

US$12.99

Apple Pie Logs

US$9.99

Big Mamas Pumpkin Cheesecake

US$7.99

Cherry Cheesecake Calzone

Folded dough filled with cheesecake filling, graham crackers and cherry pie filling. Topped with cinnamon butter and graham cracker crumbles

US$12.99

Fried Dough Bites

US$7.99

Blueberry Cheescake Calzone

Folded dough filled with cheesecake filling, blueberry pie filling and graham crackers, topped with cinnamon butter and graham cracker crumbles

US$12.99

Cinnamon Fried Dough

US$7.99

Cheesecake Calzone

Folded dough filled with Cheesecake filling and graham crackers. Topped with cinnamon butter and graham cracker crumbles

US$12.99

(Big Mamas) Strawberry Crunch Cheesecake

US$8.99

Cinnamon Knots

US$6.59

S'mores Calzone

With icing. Folded dough filled with marshmallows, chocolate chips. Topped with graham cracker crumbs.

US$10.99

Cherry Pie Calzone

Folded dough filled with cherry pie filling, graham crackers. Topped with cinnamon butter and graham cracker crumble.

US$12.99

Deep Fried Nutter Butters (6)

US$8.99

Chips Ahoy! Calzone

Folded dough filled with soft Chips ahoy cookies and marshmallows. Topped with cinnamon butter and cookie crumbles

US$12.99

Cheesecake Filled Churros W/Icing

US$8.99

Rasberry Cheesecake Bites (4)

4 deep fried raspberry cheesecake logs served with icing cup

US$8.99

Fried Oreos (6)

US$8.99

Blueberry Pie Calzone

Folded dough filled with blueberry pie filling and graham crackers. Topped with cinnamon butter and graham cracker crumbles

US$12.99

Cookie Monster Personal Dessert Pizza

Cinnamon butter base topped with Chips Ahoy, Nutter Butters, Marshmallows, and Crumbled Graham crackers with a chocolate drizzle on top

US$10.99

Apple Pie Calzone

Folded dough filled with apple pie filling and graham cracker. Topped with cinnamon butter and graham cracker crumble.

US$12.99

Cake Boss Rainbow Sprinkle Layer Cake

US$8.99

Buffalo Popcorn Chicken W/Blue Cheese

US$8.99

Fried Cheese Curds W/Maranera

1/2 lb of premium Wisconsin cheese curds served with our house made marinera sauce

US$8.99

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pizza 10"

US$9.99

Philly Steak Eggrolls (3) W/A1

3 Philly steak egg rolls served with A1 Sauce

US$8.99

Buffalo Egg Rolls (3) W/Blue Cheese

US$8.99

Battered Pickle Spears (6)

Our battered pickle spears served with buttermilk ranch dressing

US$8.99

Battered Cauliflower W/Ranch

1/2 lb battered cauliflower served with buttermilk ranch dipping sauce

US$8.99

Handcut Fries

Only the finest hand cut Idaho potatoes. They are fried till golden brown and served with ketchup

US$0.00

Buffalo Chicken Wing Dip W/ Housmade Tortilla Chips

US$11.99

Jalapeno Poppers (6) W/Ranch

With Ranch

US$8.99

Deep Fried Meatballs (5) W/Maranera

5 deep fried meatballs with our house made marinera dipping sauce

US$7.99

Chicken Tenders

Our select chicken tenders are fried golden brown and served with bbq dipping sauce. Add hand cut fries for only 2.99

US$8.99

Garlic Knots (6)

US$6.99

Garlic Cheese Breadsticks

Our house made dough lathered with garlic butter and topped with a generous amount of mozzarella cheese. It’s then baked and topped with Italian spices and served with our house made marinera

US$10.99

Garlic Knots (12)

12 freshly baked dough knots lathered with our house made garlic butter and topped with parm and oregano

US$8.99

Buffalo Cauliflower W/Blue Cheese

US$8.99

Fried Mushrooms W/Ranch

1/2 lb jumbo battered mushrooms served with buttermilk ranch dipping sauce

US$8.99

Calamari Rings W/Maranera

A generous portion of fried calamari rings served with our house made marinera sauce

US$10.99

Pepperoni Pizza Logs (5) W/Maranera

US$8.99

Mozzarella Sticks (6) W/Maranera

6 premium mozzarella sticks served with our house made marinera

US$7.99

Garlic Breadsticks

Our house made dough brushed with garlic butter and topped with Italian spices. We bake it until golden brown and serve with our house made marinera sauce

US$8.99

Taco Logs (4) /Sour Cream & Salsa

US$9.99

Popcorn Chicken W/Bbq

US$8.99

Appetizers

Gyros

Chicken Gyro

Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, & Tzatziki

US$10.99

Chicken Gyro Wrap Dinner

US$12.99

Steak Gyro Wrap

US$10.99

Chicken Gyro Wrap

US$10.99

Lamb Gyro Wrap

US$10.99

Lamb Gyro Dinner

Dinner Comes with Fries

US$12.99

Steak Gyro

Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, & Tzatziki

US$10.99

Steak Gyro Wrap Dinner

US$12.99

Lamb Gyro

Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, & Tzatziki

US$10.99

Lamb Gyro Wrap Dinner

US$12.99

Steak Gyro Dinner

Dinner Comes with Fries

US$12.99

Chicken Gyro Dinner

Dinner Comes with Fries

US$12.99

Three Cheese Quesadilla

US$12.99

Chicken Philly Quesadilla

US$12.99

Angus Beef Quesadilla

Chopped angus beef, mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, seared in an xl wrap and served with sour cream and salsa

US$12.99

Greek Quesadilla

US$12.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch Quesadilla

US$12.99

Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla

US$12.99

Boom Boom Chicken Quesadilla

Grilled chicken, mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, boom boom sauce. Seared in an xl wrap. Served with sour cream and salsa

US$12.99

Steak Philly Quesadilla

US$12.99

Steak Quesadilla

US$12.99

Chicken Quesadilla

US$12.99

Grilled Chicken And Spinach Quesadilla

US$12.99

Bacon, Egg, And Cheese Quesadilla

Bacon, scrambled eggs, mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese. Seared in an xl wrap and served with sour cream and salsa

US$14.99

Quesadilla

Entrees

Philly Steak Mac

US$13.99

Creamy Lemon Chicken Pasta

Spaghetti with Fried chicken cutlets and our creamy lemon sauce

US$13.99

Baked Ziti Dinner

US$13.99

Boom Boom Tender Dinner

Boom boom tenders with a side of fries

US$13.99

Three Cheese Mac

Elbow macaroni, cheese sauce, mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese. Baked and served with garlic knots

US$13.99

Chicken Broccoli Alfredo Dinner

US$13.99

Eggplant Parmigiana Dinner

US$13.99

Buffalo Tender Dinner

Buffalo tenders served with fries and blue cheese

US$13.99

Chicken Riggies

US$13.99

Spaghetti With Meatball Dinner

Spaghetti, housemade mariners, meatballs, topped with parm and oregano. Served with garlic knots

US$13.99

Chicken Tender Dinner

US$10.99

Rasta Pasta

Penne pasta, grilled chicken, creamy jerk sauce

US$13.99

Chicken Parmigiana

US$13.99

Chicken & Waffle Sliders

US$13.99

Chicken Florentine

Penne pasta, spinach cream sauce, grilled chicken, parm, oregano

US$13.99

Buffalo Chicken Mac

US$13.99

Kickin Cajun Chicken Alfredo

Penne pasta , Cajun Alfredo, grilled chicken

US$13.99

Classic Poutine Fries

Large fries with hot brown gravy and Wisconsin cheese curds

US$12.99

Everything Fries

US$12.99

Pepperoni Pizza Fries

Crispy fries topped with pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese and pepperoni

US$12.99

Nacho Fries

Fries, nacho cheese, jalapenos

US$12.99

Loaded Funnel Cake Fries

Funnel cake fries topped with mini marshmallows, chocolate syrup, graham cracker crumble and powdered sugar

US$12.99

Loaded Fries

US$12.99

Firework Fries

Large fries fire toasted with mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, breaded chicken, jalapenos, ranch and boom boom drizzles

US$12.99

Cheeseburger Fries

Crispy fries, topped with mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, chopped angus beef, toasted in oven

US$12.99

Greek Fries

Crispy fries topped with chopped lamb gyro, crumbly blue, and taziki sauce

US$12.99

Montreal Steak Fries

Crispy fries, stopped with mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, shaved steak, Montreal season

US$12.99

Pizza Fries

US$12.99

Gourmet French Fries